Heretic (2024) by Scott Beck, Bryan Woods

“Heretic” (2024) is a psychological horror film directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, known for their work on A Quiet Place. The plot follows two Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (played by Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (played by Chloe East), who visit a remote residence where they encounter the enigmatic and sinister Mr. Reed (played by Hugh Grant). What begins as a routine mission quickly spirals into a tense and dangerous psychological confrontation that challenges their faith and personal beliefs. Set against a cold, desolate backdrop, the film masterfully blends atmospheric tension with deep philosophical debates, exploring themes of belief, doubt, power dynamics, and isolation.

Boasting a modest production budget of $10 million, Heretic exceeded expectations both critically and commercially, earning $51.9 million at the global box office. Distributed by A24, the film garnered significant acclaim for its minimalist yet impactful storytelling, haunting cinematography by Chung-hoon Chung, and standout performances, particularly by Hugh Grant. Its thought-provoking narrative has positioned it as a key example of the evolving psychological horror trend in modern cinema.

Accolades, Awards, and Nominations:

• Golden Globe Nominations: 

• Independent Spirit Awards: 

• Critics’ Choice Awards: 

• Budget: $10 million.

• Opening Weekend (Domestic): $11 million.

• Domestic Gross: $31 million.

• International Gross: $20.9 million.

• Total Worldwide Gross: $51.9 million.

Despite its modest budget, Heretic became a commercial success, thanks to positive critical reception and word-of-mouth marketing. Its performance was particularly strong in Europe, where audiences appreciated its intellectual approach to horror.

The film’s critical acclaim and box office success have prompted discussions about expanding the Heretic universe. While no official sequels are announced, Beck and Woods have hinted at the possibility of exploring new characters or narratives within the same thematic universe.

Production and Distribution:

• Production Companies: 

  • Beck/Woods

  • Shiny Penny Productions

  • Catchlight Studios

• Distributor:

• Filming Locations:

  Principal photography took place in British Columbia, Canada. The setting of the film—a remote, snow-covered forest—adds to the tension and claustrophobia experienced by the protagonists.

1. Faith vs. Doubt: The central conflict revolves around the missionaries’ struggle to maintain their faith in the face of relentless psychological pressure.

2. Isolation: Both physical and emotional isolation play a crucial role in heightening the horror.

3. Power Dynamics: The film examines how control can be exerted through manipulation and coercion.

4. Philosophy and Morality: Through Mr. Reed’s philosophical debates with the missionaries, the film poses deep questions about belief, truth, and morality.

• Unique Storytelling: By avoiding typical horror clichés and focusing on psychological tension, the film stands out in a crowded genre.

• Character-Driven Plot: The well-developed characters and their moral dilemmas engage the audience on a deeper level.

• Cinematography: Chung-hoon Chung’s use of stark lighting and minimal color creates a visually striking and moody atmosphere.

• Critical Praise: Positive reviews from critics helped drive audience interest.

1. Psychological Horror Revival: Heretic taps into a growing trend of horror films that prioritize atmosphere, tension, and intellectual engagement over jump scares.

2. Minimalist Casting: Similar to A Quiet Place and The Lighthouse, the film succeeds with a small cast and intimate setting.

3. Exploration of Belief Systems: Audiences are increasingly drawn to films that challenge religious and philosophical ideologies.

• There is an increasing demand for films that combine entertainment with intellectual depth. Psychological and philosophical horror films have gained popularity as audiences seek more thought-provoking content.

• Minimalist filmmaking with high-quality storytelling is becoming a key factor in the success of indie and mid-budget films.

• Societal interest in exploring existential themes and questioning traditional belief systems has grown in recent years. This reflects a broader cultural shift toward introspection and critical thinking.

• The rise of social media discussions around films has amplified the visibility of thought-provoking cinema, with audiences seeking out movies that spark conversation.

• Consumers are gravitating toward films that offer unique perspectives and challenge conventional narratives. They are looking for immersive experiences that engage both emotionally and intellectually.

• The popularity of streaming platforms has increased accessibility to niche films, allowing more viewers to discover and appreciate independent productions like Heretic.

Consumer Motivation to Watch Movie:

• Curiosity about the premise: The unique plot involving faith and psychological tension intrigues audiences.

• Critical acclaim: Positive reviews and award nominations boost interest.

• Hugh Grant’s performance: His departure from typical roles to play a sinister character attracts viewers.

• A24’s reputation: The studio’s track record for delivering high-quality indie films draws loyal fans.

• Blend intellectual depth with genre conventions: Audiences are increasingly seeking films that combine entertainment with thought-provoking content. Creating stories that offer more than just superficial scares can elevate a horror film from being forgettable to memorable.

• Focus on atmosphere and minimalism: Films like Heretic have shown that small casts, isolated settings, and intense character interactions can be more effective than large-scale productions in delivering tension and emotional engagement.

• Develop multifaceted characters: A key factor in Heretic’s success was the depth of its characters. By crafting protagonists and antagonists with complex motivations and beliefs, filmmakers can create lasting impressions.

• Invest in high-concept, low-budget films: The success of Heretic highlights the profitability of well-executed films with modest budgets. Producers should seek out projects that combine artistic vision with commercial appeal.

• Capitalize on festival circuits: Early premieres at prestigious festivals like TIFF can build critical buzz and increase a film’s visibility. This strategy has worked well for A24 in positioning its films as must-see events.

• Leverage partnerships with auteur-driven studios: Collaborating with studios like A24 that focus on unique, auteur-driven projects can enhance a film’s brand and ensure quality distribution.

• Explore themes of belief and morality: As seen in Heretic, narratives that delve into philosophical or moral dilemmas resonate deeply with modern audiences. Writers should incorporate such themes to elevate genre films.

• Craft dialogue that challenges the audience: One of the film’s standout features was its intellectual dialogue, which engaged viewers on a deeper level. Writers should focus on creating conversations that provoke thought and discussion.

• Emphasize psychological conflict: Internal and interpersonal conflicts are key to maintaining tension in psychological horror. Writers should prioritize these elements to create emotionally engaging stories.

• Align with films that provoke thought: Partnering with films that challenge societal norms and spark conversations can enhance a brand’s image as forward-thinking and socially aware.

• Utilize content-driven marketing: Brands can create campaigns that revolve around the film’s key themes, encouraging audience participation and engagement.

• Collaborate on exclusive experiences: Hosting screenings, panel discussions, or themed events related to thought-provoking films can help brands connect with niche, engaged audiences.

• Embrace cross-genre storytelling: Combining elements of horror with drama, thriller, and even philosophical discourse can attract diverse audiences.

• Leverage digital platforms for promotion: With increasing digital consumption, filmmakers should create teaser content, behind-the-scenes features, and interactive marketing campaigns that engage audiences online.

• Experiment with narrative structure: Non-linear storytelling or multiple perspectives can add layers to a film, making it more engaging and rewatchable.

• Diversify distribution channels: Beyond theatrical releases, producers should explore digital platforms, streaming services, and international markets to maximize a film’s reach.

• Focus on global appeal: While maintaining local authenticity, producers should aim for themes and stories that resonate universally, increasing the potential for international success.

• Offer director-driven content: Giving directors creative freedom can result in more unique and compelling films, which tend to stand out in a crowded market.

• Incorporate cultural and societal trends: Writing stories that reflect current societal issues can make films more relevant and appealing to contemporary audiences.

• Prioritize character development: Strong, well-rounded characters are crucial for audience engagement. Writers should focus on creating protagonists and antagonists with clear, compelling arcs.

• Utilize immersive world-building: Even in minimalist settings, detailed world-building can enhance the viewer’s experience and immersion in the story.

• Partner with rising filmmakers: Supporting emerging talent can create long-term brand associations with innovation and creativity.

• Create branded content tied to films: Develop short films, documentaries, or web series that tie into a film’s themes, offering additional value to audiences.

• Engage through social media storytelling: Use social media platforms to tell interactive stories, share behind-the-scenes content, and create buzz around film partnerships.

“Heretic” (2024) is a cerebral psychological horror film directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods. It tells the story of two young Mormon missionaries who find themselves trapped in a chilling mind game orchestrated by a mysterious man, Mr. Reed. As their faith is tested, the film delves into deep philosophical questions about belief, doubt, and human nature.

Praised for its atmospheric tension, thought-provoking narrative, and outstanding performances—particularly by Hugh Grant—the film became a critical and commercial success. Produced on a modest budget and distributed by A24, Heretic grossed over $51 million worldwide, proving the viability of intellectual horror in modern cinema. With its minimalist approach, compelling dialogue, and rich thematic exploration, the film has set a new standard for psychological horror.